[Brain Tennis]

[] At What Cost Transhumanity?

 

About Brain Tennis

Brain Tennis Archive
[spacer gif]
[Paulina Borsook]

Paulina Borsook says she's "Wired's only regular feminist/humanist/
Luddite/skeptic contributor." She's also written for Suck and Newsweek, and recently examined cyberliber-
tarianism in Mother Jones.


[Max More]

Max More is president of the Extropy Institute and editor of Extropy. His writings include "On Becoming Posthuman" and "Extropian Principles," which herald biological and neurological augmentation.



Search the Wired Archive for related topics

[]
Yesterday, Max More laid down his racket after insisting that "growing into posthumans ... means augmenting, not diminishing, ourselves." Today, Paulina does the same, only by questioning whether tweaking her chemistry would amount to "self-love or self-loathing." Which side do you come down on? Discuss in Threads....

Wednesday, 21 August 1996
Post No. 8 of 8
by Paulina Borsook

 

Christopher Reeve is still Christopher Reeve; would he still be, or feel so, in Michael J. Fox's body?

Max, you and I are really asking: "What is the irreducible essence (some might call it soul) of an individual? What makes us human, and not something else?"

The notion of "species" is as hard to demarcate as that of sexual orientation. It's easy to remark the difference in speciation between a loris and the sacred hamadrayad baboon; less so between a Texas red wolf and a Canadian timber wolf. Which is to say by analogy, Max, that you and I are on different points, perhaps on the semantic continuum, of where we define what Homo sapiens is - and where it leaves off to become something else.

Aldous Huxley had it right with Brave New World's monthly mandated, chemically induced Violent Passion Surrogates.

Finally, it is a real question whether sucking jowls, enlarging breasts, straightening noses to fiddle with genetic endowment and ethnic origins (the Extropian equivs would be more profound surgical interventions: changing the mix of slow-twitch vs. fast-twitch muscle fibers, brain shunts for the MDA of the future) are acts of self-love or self-loathing. Is it self-mutilation, self-annihilation - a sense of fundamentally not being all right the way you are - or merely reaching for the stars?

No doubt who I want to make love with is as driven by biologically predetermined pheromone receptors as by higher brain functions. How much would it tinker with my sense of self to tweak my chemistry so that choice of potential Love Things was infinitely variable, as the mood struck me? As for augmenting sensation, it's always seemed that it's how I felt about the guy, nothing that didn't come from within, that determined the quality of the experience.


Join Paulina and Max for a live audio debate Friday, 23 August at 11 a.m. PDT in Wired Arena

 


Click Here to go back to the start of the Debate

Back

Copyright © 1994-99 Wired Digital Inc. All rights reserved.